Season 2

Sixteen-year-old Judy Rawlings vanishes in 2001 after a midnight ride with a friend, then her body is found in the woods a few weeks later.

Fifty-one-year-old Robin Pope goes missing, then, three weeks later, her decomposed body washes ashore just a mile from her ex-husband's home.

Twenty-three-year-old Codi Joyce ends up dead after a brawl at a house party in 2015, yet nobody has been charged for his death, and witnesses won’t talk.

In 2015, Devan Schmidt's half-naked and bruised body is found in her home; the toxicology report indicates a possible overdose, but there are also signs of foul play.

In 1996, beloved teacher Norma Luobikis is found stabbed to death in her home, and evidence suggests an intimate bond between the victim and her killer.

Twenty-eight-year-old Sharon Robinson is found murdered near New Orleans; detectives suspect her abusive police officer boyfriend.

In 2013, 22-year-old Amber Bass was gunned down in her own driveway, following a night out with friends. It is discussed whether this was just a random act of violence, or if the revelation of a love-triangle forced the hand of a jealous lover.

In 2010, Amber Jackson, 57, disappears from her Kauai, Hawaii, home, only to be found days later deep in the wilderness and bludgeoned to death.