Season 1

In the premiere of Carter’s Mafia, the players meet for the first time and dive headfirst into their first challenge - a chaotic, water-soaked showdown with an unexpected twist. While everyone’s smiling for now, two secret Mafia members are already plotting their first elimination.

The players learn who the Mafia has targeted and now must vote to eliminate one of their own. Paranoia and suspicion run rampant as alliances crumble and friends turn into enemies. To make matters worse, a revealing round of Blocks of Truth threatens to expose secrets and stir the pot even further.

The game ends tonight. After rounds of lying, scheming, and backstabbing, only a few players remain. Who can be trusted? Who’s still hiding behind a mask? In the final round of Carter’s Mafia, it’s Innocents vs Mafia in a high-stakes battle of deception. Tensions explode, alliances are shattered, and secrets come to light in the most dramatic episode yet. With the final vote looming, every move counts. Will the Mafia take control… or will the Innocents survive the night?