Season 1

A gunman kills a University of Kentucky football player at his birthday party. Despite a house full of witnesses, no one saw the shooter. But as police investigate, suspicion closes in on his closest friends who were there that night.

A mysterious killer murders the star of a community theater production of "Fiddler on the Roof" the day after a cast party. As the town grieves young artist Jessie Blodgett, her friends grow concerned that the culprit is someone within their inner circle.

When a California teen disappears, the whole town feels on edge; as suspicion turns inward, her closest friends begin to wonder if the danger has been beside them all along, hidden in the familiar faces of classmates with something dark to hide.

When a middle schooler vanishes without a trace, suspicion quickly falls on the new circle of older friends she's been spending time with. As family and friends dig deeper, secrets unravel, and the line between loyalty and betrayal starts to blur.

Best friends take a girl's trip before applying to grad school. When one of them doesn't make it home, everyone wonders what happened in Vegas? As the stakes continue to rise, sharing long-hidden secrets may be the only chance at justice.

A killer stabs a UCLA student to death in a train tunnel known for its connection to the Manson murders. Occult rumors then begin to spread until another missing friend redirects suspicion to the victim's inner circle.