Episodes
1. Almost Like a Prayer
7.6
March 19, 2025
50 min
Reeling from the grief of a failed adoption, the Barnett family gets a second chance when they get a call about a little girl named Natalia.
Guest Stars:
Jenny O'Hara, Mary Birdsong, Kario Marcel, Indra Juniper, Liam Fountain
2. Jump the Jitters Out
6.9
March 19, 2025
52 min
Natalia starts school, and Kristine's suspicions about the adoption deepen. Michael receives unexpected news at work.
Guest Stars:
Jenny O'Hara, Kario Marcel, Indra Juniper, Kyle Bornheimer, Maria McCann
3. Ghosts Everywhere
7.0
March 26, 2025
49 min
Kristine investigates Natalia's age. As she doubles down on her suspicions, Jacob's star rises and Michael's web of lies spins further.
Guest Stars:
Jenny O'Hara, Kyle Bornheimer, Kelly Sry, Kor Wren, David Paymer
4. Right There in Black and White
6.5
April 2, 2025
47 min
Michael and Kristine's marriage reaches a breaking point as their differing perspectives on Natalia threaten to tear them apart. When the stakes become dangerous, Kristine draws a line.
Guest Stars:
Jenny O'Hara, David Paymer, Sofia Hublitz, Aida Turturro, Geoffrey Arend
5. Too Hurty Without It
7.5
April 9, 2025
47 min
Left to her own devices, Natalia faces her new circumstances and how the world sees her.
Guest Stars:
Reydon Smith, Jacqueline Emerson, Jane Adams, Taj Speights, Julie Chang
6. Not Today Satan
6.2
April 16, 2025
51 min
Natalia questions whether she can trust an unexpected set of allies. As questions about her past arise, painful memories are unearthed.
Guest Stars:
Kelsey Howard, Jerod Haynes, Stacie Greenwell, Rupali Redd, Zakai Biagas Bey
7. If You Tell a Story Well Enough
7.0
April 23, 2025
57 min
Just as the Barnetts think they've distanced themselves from Natalia, Detective Drysdale takes up her case to challenge her re-aging.
Guest Stars:
David Paymer, Robert Paterno, Gail Rastorfer, Emily Berry, Jerod Haynes
